How to Handle Founder Equity Splits in Your Startup

October 16, 2024

1. Initiate the Founders' Chat

So, you've got your brilliant idea, your enthusiastic team, and a whole lot of adrenaline pumping through your veins. You're ready to dive into the world of startups. But wait! Before you take the plunge, there's one crucial conversation you need to have. Yes, my friend, it's time to talk about equity splits.

1.1. Set the stage for open dialogue

First things first, create a safe and open environment for this discussion. Remember, this isn't just about numbers and percentages, it's about respect, trust, and future expectations. So, set the stage. Choose a comfortable and neutral location, preferably away from the daily hustle of work. A calm and relaxed atmosphere can do wonders for an open and honest conversation.

Now, this might sound a bit formal, but it's worth considering having an agenda for this meeting. It helps to keep the conversation focused and ensures that all important aspects are covered. Plus, it's always good to have a plan, right?

1.2. Break the ice with a casual talk

Let's be honest, talking about equity splits can be a bit awkward. So, start with some casual chit-chat. Discuss the latest cricket match, the new restaurant in town, or the latest Netflix series everyone's binge-watching. This will help to break the ice and make everyone feel more comfortable.

Once the initial awkwardness is out of the way, gently steer the conversation towards the main topic. Remember, the goal is to have a constructive dialogue, not a heated debate. So, keep the tone friendly and respectful.

2. Dive into the Concept of Equity

Now that you've set the stage and broken the ice, it's time to dive into the meaty stuff - the concept of equity. This is where things can get a bit complicated, but don't worry, I'm here to guide you through it.

2.1. Define equity in startup terms

So, what exactly is equity? In simple terms, equity is the ownership interest in a company. It represents your share of the company's value. In a startup, equity is often given in exchange for a contribution to the company, which could be in the form of capital, intellectual property, or even sweat equity (i.e., hard work).

Think of your startup as a pie. The equity represents the slices of the pie. The size of each slice depends on the value of the contribution made by each founder.

2.2. Discuss the importance of equity

Equity is not just about ownership, it's about motivation and commitment. It's a way of acknowledging the contributions made by each founder and incentivizing them to work towards the success of the startup. It's a powerful tool for aligning the interests of the founders with the interests of the company.

Moreover, equity splits can have a significant impact on the future of the startup. They can influence the decision-making process, the distribution of profits, and even the outcome of a potential sale or merger. So, it's crucial to get them right from the start.

3. Unpack the Different Types of Equity Splits

When it comes to equity splits, there's no one-size-fits-all approach. Different startups may opt for different types of equity splits depending on their unique circumstances and needs. Let's unpack the two main types - equal and unequal equity splits.

3.1. Explore equal equity splits

Equal equity splits, as the name suggests, involve dividing the equity equally among the founders. For example, if there are three founders, each would get one-third of the equity. This type of split is simple and straightforward, and it can work well in situations where all founders are making similar contributions and have similar roles and responsibilities.

However, equal equity splits can also lead to problems down the line. What if one founder ends up contributing more than the others? What if one founder leaves the startup early? These are some of the potential issues that need to be considered.

3.2. Delve into unequal equity splits

Unequal equity splits involve dividing the equity in a way that reflects the unique contributions of each founder. This could be based on factors like the amount of capital invested, the value of the intellectual property provided, or the level of commitment and involvement in the startup.

While this type of split can be more fair and equitable, it can also be more complex and contentious. It requires a clear and objective assessment of each founder's contributions, which can be a challenging task. It also requires a high level of transparency and open communication among the founders.

4. Deliberate on the Factors Influencing Equity Splits

Deciding on the right equity split is not a simple task. It involves considering a range of factors and making some tough decisions. Let's deliberate on some of the key factors that can influence equity splits.

4.1. Discuss contribution of each founder

One of the main factors to consider is the contribution of each founder. This includes not only the capital invested but also the time and effort put into the startup, the skills and expertise brought to the table, and the value of any intellectual property provided.

But how do you quantify these contributions? It's not an exact science, but it's important to have a clear and honest discussion about it. Consider the value that each founder brings to the startup, both in terms of tangible and intangible contributions. And remember, it's not just about what has been contributed so far, but also what is expected in the future.

4.2. Consider the risk taken by each founder

Another important factor is the risk taken by each founder. Starting a business is a risky venture, and those who take on more risk should be rewarded accordingly. This could include factors like leaving a stable job to join the startup, relocating to a new city, or putting personal assets on the line.

Again, quantifying risk can be tricky, but it's an important part of the discussion. Consider the sacrifices made by each founder and the potential downside they face if the startup fails. This can help to ensure that the equity split reflects the level of risk taken by each founder.

4.3. Evaluate the future roles of the founders

Lastly, consider the future roles of the founders. Who will be the CEO? Who will be in charge of product development, marketing, or finance? These roles can have a significant impact on the success of the startup, and they should be reflected in the equity split.

But remember, roles can change over time, and the equity split should be flexible enough to accommodate these changes. Consider setting up a vesting schedule (more on this later) to ensure that the equity split remains fair and equitable over time.

5. Put the Spotlight on Vesting Schedules

Speaking of vesting schedules, let's put the spotlight on this important concept. A vesting schedule is a mechanism that can help to ensure that the equity split remains fair and equitable over time. Let's dive into it.

5.1. Define vesting schedules

A vesting schedule is a timeline that determines when a founder's equity becomes "vested", i.e., fully owned by the founder. Until the equity is vested, the founder doesn't fully own it and can't sell it or transfer it to someone else.

Typically, a vesting schedule spans over a period of 4 years, with a one-year "cliff". This means that if a founder leaves the startup within the first year, they get no equity. After the first year, the equity starts to vest gradually, usually on a monthly basis.

5.2. Discuss the benefits of vesting schedules

Vesting schedules have several benefits. First, they help to protect the startup from a situation where a founder leaves early and walks away with a large chunk of equity. This can be particularly important in the early stages of a startup, when the team is still figuring things out and there's a higher risk of founders leaving.

Second, vesting schedules can help to motivate and retain founders. Knowing that they will gradually earn more equity over time can incentivize founders to stay with the startup and work towards its success.

Lastly, vesting schedules can provide a fair and objective way to adjust the equity split over time. If a founder's role or contribution changes, the vesting schedule can be adjusted accordingly.

6. Decipher the Legal Framework for Equity Splits in India

Now that we've covered the basics of equity splits and vesting schedules, let's delve into the legal framework for equity splits in India. Understanding the legal aspects can help to ensure that your equity split agreement is legally sound and enforceable.

6.1. Discuss the Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act, 2013 is the main legislation governing companies in India, including startups. It provides the legal framework for the issuance of shares and the rights and obligations of shareholders.

Under the Companies Act, equity shares must be issued at a price that is not less than the face value of the shares. This means that you can't issue shares for free or at a nominal price. The price must reflect the fair value of the shares, which can be determined based on the value of the startup's assets, its future earnings potential, or other relevant factors.

The Companies Act also provides for the issuance of sweat equity shares to employees or directors in recognition of their intellectual property contributions or know-how. This can be a useful tool for startups that want to reward their founders or key employees with equity.

6.2. Explore the Indian Contract Act, 1872

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 is another important piece of legislation that can impact equity splits. It provides the legal framework for contracts, including agreements between founders.

Under the Indian Contract Act, an agreement between founders must be in writing and must be supported by consideration (i.e., something of value) to be legally enforceable. This means that if you promise to give equity to a founder in exchange for their contribution, you need to put it in writing and ensure that the contribution is actually made.

The Indian Contract Act also provides for the enforcement of contracts. If a founder breaches the agreement, the other founders can take legal action to enforce the agreement and recover damages.

7. Contemplate the Role of Advisors and Investors

Equity splits are not just about the founders. Advisors and investors can also play a significant role. Let's contemplate their role and how they can influence equity splits.

7.1. Discuss how advisors influence equity splits

Advisors can bring valuable expertise and connections to a startup, and it's common for startups to reward them with equity. However, the amount of equity given to advisors should be carefully considered.

Typically, advisors receive a much smaller share of equity compared to founders, usually in the range of 0.1% to 1%. The exact amount depends on the value that the advisor brings to the startup and the level of their involvement.

Keep in mind that giving equity to advisors reduces the share of equity available for the founders. So, it's important to ensure that the value received from the advisor justifies the equity given to them.

7.2. Delve into the impact of investors on equity splits

Investors can have a significant impact on equity splits. When an investor puts money into a startup, they usually receive equity in return. This means that the founders' share of equity is diluted.

The amount of dilution depends on the amount of investment and the valuation of the startup. The higher the investment and the lower the valuation, the more the founders' equity is diluted.

However, investment can also increase the value of the startup, which can benefit the founders even if their percentage of equity is reduced. So, it's a balancing act between maintaining equity control and attracting investment to grow the startup.

8. Discuss the Pros and Cons of Different Equity Split Models

By now, you've got a pretty good idea of the different factors that can influence equity splits. But how do you choose the right model for your startup? Let's discuss the pros and cons of different equity split models to help you make an informed decision.

8.1. Talk about the benefits of each model

Equal equity splits have the benefit of simplicity and fairness. They can help to avoid conflicts and ensure that all founders feel valued and motivated. They can also send a positive signal to investors and employees about the unity and commitment of the founding team.

Unequal equity splits, on the other hand, can provide a more accurate reflection of the contributions and risks of each founder. They can help to ensure that the equity split is fair and equitable, and they can provide a mechanism for rewarding founders who make a greater contribution or take on more risk.

Vesting schedules can provide a way to adjust the equity split over time based on the ongoing contributions of the founders. They can help to protect the startup from early departures and incentivize founders to stay and contribute to the startup's success.

8.2. Highlight the downsides of each model

Equal equity splits can also have downsides. They can lead to resentment and conflict if one founder ends up contributing more than the others. They can also create problems if one founder leaves early and takes a large chunk of equity with them.

Unequal equity splits can be complex and contentious. They require a clear and objective assessment of each founder's contributions, which can be challenging and can lead to disagreements. They also require a high level of transparency and open communication, which can be difficult to maintain.

Vesting schedules can be complex to set up and manage. They can also create uncertainty for the founders, as their equity ownership is contingent on their continued involvement in the startup.

9. Decide on the Best Equity Split for Your Startup

Now that you've explored the different models and factors, it's time to make a decision. Choosing the right equity split for your startup is a crucial decision that can have a lasting impact on your startup's future. So, take your time and make sure you get it right.

9.1. Evaluate your options

Start by evaluating your options. Consider the pros and cons of each model and how they align with your startup's needs and circumstances. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all approach. The best equity split for your startup depends on a range of factors, including the contributions of each founder, the risks taken, the future roles, and the potential impact of advisors and investors.

Consider using a tool or a spreadsheet to help you evaluate your options. This can help you to visualize the different scenarios and make a more informed decision.

9.2. Reach a consensus

Once you've evaluated your options, it's time to reach a consensus. This is a collective decision that should be made by all founders. It's important to ensure that everyone is on board and comfortable with the decision.

Remember, this is not just about numbers and percentages, it's about respect and trust. So, make sure that the decision is made in a fair and transparent manner, and that all founders feel valued and appreciated.

10. Document Your Equity Split Agreement

Once you've reached a decision, it's time to put it in writing. Documenting your equity split agreement is a crucial step that can help to prevent misunderstandings and conflicts down the line. So, don't skip this step.

10.1. Draft the agreement

Start by drafting the agreement. This should include the details of the equity split, the vesting schedule, the roles and responsibilities of each founder, and any other relevant terms and conditions. It's a good idea to get legal advice to ensure that the agreement is legally sound and enforceable.

Remember, this is a legal document that can have significant implications for the founders and the startup. So, take your time and make sure you get it right.

10.2. Review and sign the agreement

Once the draft is ready, review it carefully. Make sure that it accurately reflects the agreed equity split and that all terms and conditions are clear and understandable. If there are any discrepancies or ambiguities, address them before signing the agreement.

Once everyone is satisfied with the agreement, sign it. This formalizes the equity split and makes it legally binding. Keep a copy of the agreement for your records and make sure that all founders have a copy as well.

11. Keep the Door Open for Future Changes

Finally, remember that equity splits are not set in stone. They can and should be adjusted over time to reflect the evolving contributions and roles of the founders. So, keep the door open for future changes.

11.1. Discuss the possibility of future alterations

During your equity split discussion, bring up the possibility of future alterations. This can help to set the expectation that the equity split is not a one-time decision, but a dynamic process that can be adjusted as the startup evolves.

Discuss the circumstances under which the equity split might be revisited. This could include significant changes in the contributions or roles of the founders, the arrival of new founders, or the departure of existing founders.

11.2. Set up a process for making changes

Finally, set up a process for making changes to the equity split. This should include a mechanism for reviewing the equity split on a regular basis (e.g., annually) and a procedure for proposing and approving changes.

Remember, any changes to the equity split should be made in a fair and transparent manner, with the agreement of all founders. And, as always, any changes should be documented in a revised equity split agreement.

And there you have it - a comprehensive guide on handling founder equity splits in your Indian startup. Remember, this is a crucial decision that can shape the future of your startup, so take your time and get it right. Good luck!

Explore our startup expert-led programs or join our free community of 5,000+ Indian founders - scale with 18startup!

Get started 🚀